
PlayStation and Xbox offer more of the same great games than their rivalry suggests. Clair Obscur: Expedition 33, DOOM: The Dark Ages, Baldur's Gate 3 and Indiana Jones and the Great Circle are playable across both ecosystems. The meaningful differences emerge when a game needs a subscription, when friends use another platform, when a save file cannot follow you, or when a particular controller changes the feel of combat.
For a New Zealand player who favours cinematic single-player adventures, the PlayStation 5 has a compelling catalogue and an unusually expressive DualSense controller. Xbox Series X makes a strong case for players who rotate through many games, own older Xbox titles or split their time between console and Windows PC. Xbox Series S offers a lower-cost entry to current-generation games, accepting reduced visual headroom and an all-digital library.
PlayStation and Xbox at a glance
| Playing priority | PlayStation 5 | Xbox Series X|S |
|---|---|---|
| Story-led exclusives | Astro Bot, Marvel's Spider-Man 2 and Ghost of Yōtei make the strongest case. | Halo, Gears and a deep back catalogue remain major attractions, although more Microsoft games now release on PS5. |
| Trying many games | PlayStation Plus Extra and Deluxe offer rotating game catalogues. | Game Pass has several catalogue tiers; Ultimate includes selected new releases on day one. |
| Controller experience | DualSense haptic feedback and adaptive triggers, when supported by the game. | Familiar Xbox Wireless Controller layout; Quick Resume helps with switching between supported games. |
| Existing games | Most PS4 games are playable on PS5; older PlayStation disc generations are not broadly supported. | Thousands of supported games across Xbox One, Xbox 360 and original Xbox generations. |
| Storage expansion | Compatible, heatsink-equipped M.2 NVMe SSDs can run PS5 games directly. | Dedicated Storage Expansion Cards run current-generation games; USB drives mainly serve as storage for those titles. |
| Lower-cost hardware | PS5 Digital Edition removes the built-in disc drive. | Series S is smaller, all-digital and designed around a lower rendering target than Series X. |
A console's advertised 4K resolution or 120 frames per second is a capability, not a promise for every title. Performance mode, quality mode, ray tracing, the television's refresh rate and each developer's optimisation determine what actually appears on screen.
Game reviews: where platform choice changes the experience
Clair Obscur: Expedition 33 — storytelling with demanding combat timing
Sandfall Interactive's role-playing game takes the structure of a turn-based RPG and gives every attack, dodge and parry a real-time input. The result feels more active than a traditional menu-driven battle while retaining the satisfaction of constructing a party. Its surreal Belle Époque-inspired world, melancholy story and character relationships supply the emotional weight; the combat system supplies the tension.
Best for: players who want a substantial narrative RPG without passive battles. Trade-off: reactive defence can frustrate anyone who prefers entirely turn-based play, while exploration is more directed than in a sprawling open-world RPG. The PlayStation 5 and Xbox Series X|S versions share the central experience, so subscription availability, controller preference and any current platform-specific performance analysis are more useful than a blanket claim that one console plays it better.
Indiana Jones and the Great Circle — a cinematic adventure on both consoles
MachineGames and Bethesda place Indiana Jones in a first-person adventure built around exploration, puzzles, stealth and improvised fights. The whip matters as a traversal tool as much as a weapon. Detailed environments and the familiar archaeology-film atmosphere carry the quieter stretches; close-quarters melee is less graceful than the puzzle solving.
Its arrival on PS5 after Xbox and PC shows why older lists of Xbox exclusives become unreliable. The core content is shared. DualSense effects add texture to the PlayStation version, while PS5 Pro can offer a more refined image in supported rendering modes. The New Zealand physical edition has also illustrated a less glamorous issue: owning a disc need not eliminate a substantial download. Disc buyers with slow or restricted broadband should check installation requirements for the specific edition.
Helldivers 2 — the better test of a cross-platform friendship
Arrowhead Game Studios turns four-player cooperative shooting into organised chaos. Friendly fire, sudden enemy reinforcements, limited supplies and powerful Stratagems reward a squad that talks, improvises and accepts spectacular mistakes. The central appeal is shared problem-solving under pressure, not a traditional solo campaign. Missions can be attempted alone, but the design is markedly more demanding without a team.
PS5, Xbox Series X|S and PC players can fight together through cross-play. Cross-play does not bring cross-progression: equipment, purchases and campaign progress do not transfer between platform accounts. There is no local split-screen mode, and a stable connection is essential for its online-only design. Console players also need to factor in the paid-online requirements that apply to this paid game.
Forza Horizon 5 — an Xbox racing favourite now on PS5
Playground Games' open-world racer favours accessible handling, changing road surfaces, varied events and a festival-like sense of progression. It is designed for drivers who enjoy drifting away from a planned race to discover another challenge. A dedicated circuit simulator will offer a stricter test of racecraft; Forza Horizon 5 is at its strongest when freedom and vehicle variety take priority.
The PS5 release supports cross-play with Xbox and PC, allowing friends to form convoys across platforms. A crucial distinction remains: an existing Xbox or Windows save does not carry into the PS5 version, even when the same Microsoft account is linked. Some online statistics and published creations are shared, but the main game progress is separate.
Baldur's Gate 3 — the long-form RPG for mixed-platform groups
Larian Studios builds its fantasy RPG around consequential dialogue, party composition, Dungeons & Dragons-inspired systems and turn-based encounters where the environment can be as powerful as a spell. A fight can be resolved through positioning, improvisation or a decision made hours earlier. It rewards patient experimentation more than reflexes, and its sheer number of choices makes a second campaign feel meaningfully different.
Patch 8 brought cross-play between PS5, Xbox, PC and Mac, along with cross-platform progression through the Larian Network. Modded multiplayer needs matching compatible mods across participants, which complicates a seemingly simple invitation. Players interested in local co-op should check split-screen support for their exact hardware and game version rather than assuming that every RPG with online multiplayer also offers couch play.
DOOM: The Dark Ages — aggressive action without a co-op dependency
id Software's prequel reshapes the modern DOOM formula around a shield, heavy melee attacks and broad combat arenas. The shield can block or counter attacks and become a thrown weapon, encouraging the player to hold ground rather than remain in constant retreat. Large encounters maintain the series' brisk pacing, while the additional story scenes will appeal more to some players than others.
It is a strong fit for someone who wants a complete, intense single-player shooter on either PS5 or Xbox Series X|S. Its appeal lies in weapon feel, enemy patterns and combat rhythm, not cross-play or a paid multiplayer community.
Ghost of Yōtei and Astro Bot — the clearest PlayStation reasons
Sucker Punch Productions' Ghost of Yōtei puts Atsu's revenge story into an expansive historical-Japan-inspired setting, mixing stealth, sword styles, exploration and cinematic duels. The different weapons reward learning enemy weaknesses; the open landscape gives players room to pursue side stories between major encounters. Its scale can feel familiar to anyone fatigued by map-driven action adventures, yet its combat and visual direction provide a distinctive identity.
Team Asobi's Astro Bot takes a different route: tightly constructed 3D platforming, playful level mechanics and unusually creative use of DualSense feedback. Their appeal is highly specific, though. A player whose weekly routine revolves around racing, online shooters or Game Pass discovery will not necessarily gain the same value from them.
Cross-play, cross-save and cross-buy are three separate promises
Games advertised as “cross-platform” do not necessarily share everything. Cross-play lets people on different systems join the same multiplayer session. Cross-save or cross-progression moves progress between supported platforms. Cross-buy grants access to more than one version through a qualifying purchase. Even when a game offers two of these features, the third may be absent.
| Game | PlayStation–Xbox play | Progress between systems | Practical consequence |
|---|---|---|---|
| Helldivers 2 | Yes; PC is included. | No cross-progression. | Friends can squad up, but switching hardware means a fresh account progression path. |
| Forza Horizon 5 | Yes; cross-platform convoys. | Xbox progress does not transfer to PS5. | Existing Xbox players cannot bring their garage and campaign completion to PlayStation. |
| Baldur's Gate 3 | Yes, following Patch 8. | Cross-platform progression supported through Larian's account system. | Mixed-platform campaigns are viable; mod compatibility still needs attention. |
| Indiana Jones and the Great Circle | Not a multiplayer game. | Do not assume a purchase or save transfers between console storefronts. | Choose the version for the console you intend to use. |
Cross-play settings, linked publisher accounts, game updates and multiplayer entitlements can all prevent friends from joining even when a title advertises support.
Performance: PS5, PS5 Pro, Xbox Series X and Series S
Standard PS5 and Xbox Series X target broadly comparable high-end console experiences. Both use fast SSD storage, support hardware-accelerated ray tracing and can output up to 120Hz in compatible games. Series X has the higher theoretical graphics throughput on paper; that does not guarantee a higher frame rate or sharper image in every multiplatform release. Rendering resolution, engine design, optimisation and patches can reverse a small hardware advantage.
PS5 Pro adds more graphics headroom, 2TB of built-in SSD storage and PlayStation Spectral Super Resolution (PSSR) upscaling in supported titles. The benefit is clearest when a particular game offers an enhanced mode that improves image quality without sacrificing as much fluidity. It is an all-digital console unless an optional compatible disc drive is fitted.
Xbox Series S runs the same current-generation Xbox ecosystem at a reduced visual target. Its 1440p-oriented design is better matched to a smaller screen, a modest budget or a player unconcerned by the finest texture and ray-tracing details. Series X and PS5 are stronger options for large 4K televisions where performance modes matter. A 120Hz display, HDMI settings and variable refresh rate (VRR) support are useful only when the chosen game and display actually support them.
Controller feel also changes the result. DualSense adaptive triggers and haptics can make driving, drawing a bow or firing a weapon feel more tactile, though implementation varies widely. The Xbox Wireless Controller prioritises a conventional layout and broad familiarity. Quick Resume adds convenience when moving between several supported Xbox games; online titles may still require reconnection to their servers.

The New Zealand cost question: subscriptions, games and discs
Prices in US dollars are a poor guide to the cost of console gaming in Aotearoa. New Zealand storefronts bill in NZD, subscriptions renew unless cancelled, and local retail discounts can differ substantially from digital-store pricing. Game libraries also change over time. A title included with a subscription today is not automatically permanent, and access ordinarily ends when the relevant membership ends or the title leaves its catalogue.
As listed on the New Zealand PlayStation and Xbox stores in November 2026, the standard monthly membership prices were:
| Platform | Plan | Listed monthly price (NZD) | Main use |
|---|---|---|---|
| PlayStation Plus | Essential | NZ$17.95 | Online multiplayer for eligible paid games, monthly games and cloud saves. |
| Extra | NZ$28.95 | Essential benefits plus the downloadable Game Catalogue. | |
| Deluxe | NZ$30.95 | Extra benefits plus the Classics Catalogue and game trials. | |
| Xbox Game Pass | Essential | NZ$15.95 | A smaller game catalogue and online console multiplayer. |
| Premium | NZ$21.95 | A wider catalogue and qualifying Xbox-published games added after launch. | |
| Ultimate | NZ$32.95 | Broader access, selected day-one releases and additional benefits. |
These are monthly list prices, not quotes for a console bundle or discounted annual plan. Catalogue content, promotional terms, cloud-gaming conditions and fees can change. In New Zealand, the top PlayStation tier is called Deluxe, not the Premium tier commonly described by US and UK coverage.
The economical choice depends on habits. Someone who finishes one lengthy RPG over several months may spend less by owning it outright. A player who tries numerous games and drops those that do not click can get more value from a changing catalogue.
Paid online multiplayer is another line item. Helldivers 2 and the online mode of Forza Horizon 5 have platform-specific membership requirements. Major free-to-play games such as Fortnite and Rocket League generally do not require a paid console multiplayer membership, although purchases and optional subscriptions within the games remain separate.
Discs, old libraries and storage can outweigh graphics
A disc-capable PS5 or Xbox Series X gives a New Zealand household access to physical-game deals, borrowing, trading and resale. A PS5 Digital Edition, PS5 Pro without its optional disc drive, an all-digital Series X or any Series S cannot read game discs. Used prices, disc availability and required downloads deserve as much scrutiny as the initial hardware discount.
PS5 supports the overwhelming majority of PS4 games, including many existing digital purchases and disc copies on models with a drive. It does not simply run original PS1, PS2 or PS3 discs. Xbox Series X supports a broader backward-compatible catalogue reaching selected original Xbox and Xbox 360 games as well as Xbox One. Compatibility is title-specific, and disc ownership helps only on a console with a compatible drive.
PS5 accepts compatible M.2 NVMe expansion drives with the required cooling solution, allowing PS5 games to run from the added SSD. Xbox Series X|S uses matching-performance Storage Expansion Cards for games designed to run from fast Xbox storage. USB hard drives can hold current-generation games but generally cannot run those optimised titles directly.
What matters specifically to players in New Zealand?
Internet quality and the real download
A fibre connection is convenient for large downloads, patches and cloud gaming, yet speed alone cannot fix unstable Wi-Fi or high latency. Competitive multiplayer benefits from a stable connection and nearby regional servers; data-centre location, matchmaking population and the game itself determine ping. Remote Play and Xbox cloud gaming are different from downloading a game locally. Both add dependence on the network, with cloud streaming additionally influenced by service availability, limits and connection quality.
Household accounts, local co-op and age ratings
A local multiplayer game must explicitly support split-screen or shared-screen play. Account permissions, age restrictions, voice chat, parental controls and in-game spending settings can matter more to a younger player than whether the console targets 4K. New Zealand restricted classifications have legal force; international ESRB or PEGI labels are not substitutes for a local restriction where one applies.
Accessibility and the rest of the setup
Subtitles, control remapping, difficulty options, colour-vision settings and audio cues differ by game rather than by brand alone. A suitable headset, a readable interface and a controller that feels comfortable across long sessions can outweigh marginal graphical differences. PlayStation VR2 adds an option for PS5 owners interested in compatible virtual-reality games, but it does not make ordinary PS5 or older PS VR games automatically playable in the headset.
Which PlayStation or Xbox is the better fit?
Choose a PS5 for distinctive single-player adventures when Astro Bot, Ghost of Yōtei or Marvel's Spider-Man 2 are the games you most want to play. The DualSense and a disc-capable model strengthen that choice for tactile games and households that buy physical releases.
Choose Xbox Series X for a broad library and established Xbox purchases when backward compatibility, Quick Resume, Windows integration and Game Pass suit your routine. The Series S is a more economical route into that library for players comfortable with digital purchases and reduced graphical ambition.
Choose based on your friends rather than a platform badge if online play dominates. Helldivers 2, Baldur's Gate 3 and Forza Horizon 5 demonstrate that mixed-platform groups can work well, but their account and save-transfer rules differ sharply. A game without cross-play can still make the same console essential for a particular social circle.
Choose by the game, screen and total cost when both consoles offer the title you want. Performance targets are game-specific; hardware models differ; and subscriptions, storage, online play and physical-versus-digital pricing can reverse an apparent bargain.